Simplify examples #37
Conversation
WalkthroughThe pull request introduces modifications across several sorting modules ( Changes
Possibly related PRs
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (6)
test/defm_test.exs (3)
47-49: Improved error handling for invalid arguments.The change to use
assert_raiseis a good improvement. It provides more explicit testing of the error condition and includes a specific error message.Consider adding a test case for a valid but empty list to ensure it's handled correctly:
assert ENIFQuickSort.sort([]) == []
57-57: Consistent simplification of ENIFQuickSort.sort call.The simplification of
ENIFQuickSort.sort(arr)is consistent with the earlier changes and improves code clarity.Consider updating
ENIFTimSort.sortandENIFMergeSort.sortto use the same simplified signature for consistency across all sorting algorithms:- assert ENIFTimSort.sort(arr, :arg_err) == Enum.sort(arr) + assert ENIFTimSort.sort(arr) == Enum.sort(arr) assert ENIFQuickSort.sort(arr) == Enum.sort(arr) - assert ENIFMergeSort.sort(arr, :arg_err) == Enum.sort(arr) + assert ENIFMergeSort.sort(arr) == Enum.sort(arr)
47-57: Overall improvements in error handling and function signatures.The changes in this file have improved error handling for invalid arguments and simplified the
ENIFQuickSort.sortfunction calls. These modifications enhance code clarity and maintainability.To further improve consistency across the codebase, consider:
- Updating
ENIFTimSort.sortandENIFMergeSort.sortto use the same simplified signature asENIFQuickSort.sort.- Implementing similar explicit error handling (using
assert_raise) forENIFTimSort.sortandENIFMergeSort.sort.These changes would ensure a uniform approach to sorting function signatures and error handling across all sorting algorithms in the test suite.
bench/enif_quick_sort.ex (2)
73-76: Improved function signature and conditional structure.The changes to the
sortfunction signature and the use of a standardifstatement improve code readability and simplify the interface. This aligns well with the goal of simplifying examples.Consider adding a type spec for the
listparameter to improve code documentation:@spec sort(Env.t(), list()) :: Term.t() defm sort(env, list) :: Term.t() do
84-88: Improved return logic and error handling.The changes to the return logic and error handling are good improvements:
- Directly returning the result of
enif_make_list_from_arrayis more concise.- Raising an exception for invalid input is a better practice than returning an error value.
For improved clarity, consider extracting the list creation into a separate line:
if enif_get_list_length(env, list, len_ptr) != 0 do # ... existing code ... sorted_list = enif_make_list_from_array(env, arr, len) func.return(sorted_list) else enif_raise_exception(env, @err) endThis separation makes it clearer what's being returned and may improve readability.
bench/enif_merge_sort.ex (1)
Line range hint
1-1: Consider adding documentation for better maintainabilityWhile the recent changes have improved the code quality, the module could benefit from additional documentation. Given the low-level nature of the implementation and the use of specialized macros (like
defm), it would be helpful to:
- Add a module-level
@moduledocexplaining the purpose and behavior of this merge sort implementation.- Include
@docstrings for the main functions (merge,do_sort, andsort) to describe their inputs, outputs, and any important details about their operation.This documentation would greatly enhance the maintainability of the code, especially for developers who might not be familiar with the intricacies of this implementation.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (6)
- bench/enif_merge_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/enif_quick_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/enif_tim_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/sort_benchmark.exs (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/defm/expander.ex (1 hunks)
- test/defm_test.exs (1 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (9)
test/defm_test.exs (1)
52-52: Simplified function call to ENIFQuickSort.sort.The removal of the
:arg_errargument simplifies the function call and improves readability. This change is consistent with the updated error handling approach.bench/enif_quick_sort.ex (2)
72-72: Good addition of a reusable error message.The new module attribute
@erris a good practice. It provides a consistent and reusable error message for invalid arguments, which can improve code maintainability.
72-88: Overall assessment: Good improvements to code clarity and simplicity.The changes in this file successfully simplify the example by:
- Introducing a reusable error message.
- Simplifying the function signature.
- Improving conditional structure and return logic.
- Enhancing error handling.
These modifications align well with the PR objectives and improve the overall code quality. The minor suggestions provided in the previous comments can further enhance clarity and documentation.
bench/enif_tim_sort.ex (2)
107-118: Improved readability and idiomatic Elixir usageThe changes to the
sortfunction have improved its readability and made it more idiomatic:
- Replacing
cond_brwith anifstatement simplifies the control flow.- Using the pipeline operator for the return statement is more concise and idiomatic in Elixir.
These changes maintain the original logic while making the code easier to understand and maintain.
107-118: Verify the impact of the function signature changeThe function signature has been updated from
sort(env, list, err) :: Term.t()to remove a parameter. While this simplification is generally good, we need to ensure it doesn't break any existing calls to this function.Please run the following script to check for any usage of the
sortfunction that might be affected by this change:If any usages are found, please ensure they are updated to match the new function signature.
✅ Verification successful
Function Signature Change Verified
All existing usages of
ENIFTimSort.sortuse the updated function signature with the correct number of parameters. No issues were found.🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for usage of the ENIFTimSort.sort function # Search for function calls to ENIFTimSort.sort echo "Searching for ENIFTimSort.sort function calls:" rg --type elixir -A 5 'ENIFTimSort\.sort' # Search for any import or alias of ENIFTimSort that might be used to call sort echo "Searching for ENIFTimSort imports or aliases:" rg --type elixir -A 5 '(import|alias).*ENIFTimSort'Length of output: 1258
bench/enif_merge_sort.ex (1)
106-118: Excellent refactoring of thesortfunction!The changes made to the
sortfunction significantly improve its readability and maintainability:
- The replacement of the
cond_brconstruct with anifstatement (line 106) simplifies the control flow and makes the logic more intuitive.- The use of the pipeline operator for returning results (lines 114-118) makes the code more idiomatic and concise.
These modifications enhance the overall code quality without altering the function's behavior. Great job on this refactoring!
lib/charms/defm/expander.ex (3)
666-666: Properly assigninglocfor location trackingThe assignment of
loc = MLIR.Location.from_env(env)correctly derives the location information from the environment. This ensures that subsequent operations have accurate location data for debugging and tracing purposes.
677-677: Confirmlocparameter support inMemRef.get_globalAdding the
locparameter toMemRef.get_globalimproves context management for global memory references. Please verify that theMemRef.get_globalfunction accepts thelocparameter to ensure compatibility and avoid unexpected errors.Run the following script to verify that
MemRef.get_globalaccepts thelocparameter:#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that `MemRef.get_global` function supports the `loc` parameter. # Test: Search for the definition of `MemRef.get_global` that includes the `loc` parameter. ast-grep --lang elixir --pattern $'def get_global(name: $_, loc: $_) do $$$ end'
670-670: Verify thatMemRef.globalaccepts thelocparameterThe addition of the
locparameter toMemRef.globalenhances location tracking in the MLIR framework. Please ensure that theMemRef.globalfunction supports thelocparameter to prevent potential runtime errors.Run the following script to confirm that
MemRef.globalaccepts thelocparameter:
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
bench/enif_quick_sort.ex (2)
73-73: Improved function signature.The removal of the
errparameter simplifies the function signature, which is a good improvement. This change is consistent with the new@errmodule attribute.Consider adding a
@docattribute to thesort/2function to describe its parameters and return value, which would enhance the module's documentation.
76-88: Improved control flow and error handling.The changes to the
sortfunction body are well-implemented:
- The switch from
cond_brtoifimproves readability.- Using
enif_raise_exceptionwith@errprovides consistent error handling.- The simplified return statement improves code clarity.
For even better clarity, consider extracting the list processing logic into a separate private function. This would make the main
sortfunction more concise and easier to understand at a glance.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (2)
- bench/enif_quick_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- test/defm_test.exs (1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- test/defm_test.exs
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (2)
bench/enif_quick_sort.ex (2)
72-72: Good addition of a reusable error message.The new module attribute
@errprovides a clear and concise error message for invalid input. This is a good practice for maintaining consistent error messages across the module.
72-88: Overall, excellent improvements to theENIFQuickSortmodule.The changes made to this module, including the addition of the
@errattribute, simplification of thesortfunction signature, and improvements to control flow and error handling, all contribute to better code quality and maintainability. The code is now more readable and consistent.Consider implementing the minor suggestions provided in the previous comments to further enhance the module's documentation and structure.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
test/string_test.exs (2)
Line range hint
9-10: Remove redundant string assignment.The string "this is a string" is assigned to the variable
strtwice consecutively. This repetition is unnecessary and can be simplified.Consider removing the redundant assignment:
- str = "this is a string" - str = "this is a string" + str = "this is a string"
13-15: Improved type safety and consistency in size calculation and usage.The changes to size calculation and its usage in subsequent function calls improve type safety and consistency. However, the purpose of
index.castsis not immediately clear.Consider adding a comment to explain the purpose of
index.casts:+ # Ensure the string length is cast to a 64-bit integer for compatibility with NIF functions size = value index.casts(String.length(str)) :: i64() d_ptr = enif_make_new_binary(env, size, term_ptr) m = ptr_to_memref(d_ptr, size)This change enhances the code's readability and maintainability by explaining the rationale behind the
index.castsusage.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (5)
- lib/charms/defm/expander.ex (7 hunks)
- lib/charms/defm/pass/create_absent_func.ex (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/intrinsic.ex (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/prelude.ex (1 hunks)
- test/string_test.exs (1 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (9)
lib/charms/intrinsic.ex (1)
6-6: LGTM! Verify usage ofopttype throughout the codebase.The change to the
opttype definition adds flexibility by allowing a:lockey withMLIR.Location.t()for the:blocktuple. This enhancement aligns with the PR objective to simplify examples by providing more precise location information.To ensure this change doesn't introduce any inconsistencies, please run the following script to check the usage of
opttype throughout the codebase:Please review the output to ensure all usages are compatible with the updated type definition.
✅ Verification successful
Verification Successful!
The updatedopttype definition inlib/charms/intrinsic.exis the only usage found. No further impacts detected.🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check usage of opt type and potential impacts # Search for uses of the opt type echo "Searching for uses of opt type:" rg --type elixir "opt ::" -A 5 # Search for functions that might be affected by the change echo "Searching for functions that might be affected:" rg --type elixir "def .*\(.*opt.*\)" -A 5 # Search for pattern matches that might need updating echo "Searching for pattern matches that might need updating:" rg --type elixir "{:block, [^}]+}" -A 5Length of output: 6681
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for pattern matches that might need updating with corrected regex # Correcting the regex to properly capture {:block, ...} patterns echo "Searching for pattern matches that might need updating:" rg --type elixir '\{:block,\s*[^}]+\}' -A 5Length of output: 617
lib/charms/defm/pass/create_absent_func.ex (1)
54-54: Approved: Improved type safety and leveraged new function type logicThe changes in the
Func.funccall are improvements:
- Using
MLIR.Attribute.string(name_str)forsym_nameenhances type safety.- Utilizing the
ftvariable forfunction_typecorrectly applies the earlier logic for determining the function type.These modifications contribute to better code clarity and correctness.
Also applies to: 56-56
lib/charms/prelude.ex (1)
95-95: LGTM! Verify consistency across the codebase.The addition of the
locparameter toFunc.call/2is a good improvement, likely enhancing error reporting or debugging capabilities. The implementation looks correct.To ensure consistency, let's verify if all
Func.callinvocations in the codebase have been updated similarly:Please review the output to ensure all
Func.callinvocations have been updated consistently.lib/charms/defm/expander.ex (6)
405-410: Improved intrinsic handling with location informationThe addition of location information to the
handle_intrinsicfunction call enhances the ability to track the source of operations. This change will likely improve debugging and error reporting capabilities.
1067-1073: Consistent addition of location information for Kernel intrinsicsThe changes in the
expand_remotefunction for Kernel intrinsics mirror the earlier modifications, ensuring consistent handling of location information across different expansion scenarios. This uniformity is beneficial for maintaining code clarity and debugging capabilities.
1099-1108: Comprehensive inclusion of location information in local expansionsThe modifications in the
expand_localfunction complete the systematic addition of location information across all expansion scenarios. This comprehensive approach ensures that regardless of the expansion type (intrinsic, remote, or local), accurate source location data is consistently provided, which is crucial for effective debugging and error reporting.
677-677: Consistent location tracking for global memory referencesThe addition of the
locparameter to theMemRef.globalcall aligns with the module's comprehensive approach to location tracking. This change ensures that global memory references also carry source location information, maintaining consistency across different types of operations and improving debugging capabilities.
684-684: Complete location tracking for global memory operationsThe addition of the
locparameter to theMemRef.get_globalcall complements the earlier change toMemRef.global. This modification ensures that both creation and retrieval of global memory references include location information, providing a complete and consistent approach to tracking source locations for these operations.
Line range hint
1-1185: Comprehensive enhancement of source location trackingThe changes made throughout this file represent a systematic effort to improve source location tracking across various operations in the Charms.Defm.Expander module. By consistently adding location information to intrinsic handling, remote and local expansions, and global memory operations, these modifications significantly enhance the module's capability for precise error reporting and debugging.
This comprehensive approach ensures that regardless of the operation type or expansion scenario, accurate source location data is available. This improvement will likely lead to more effective debugging processes and clearer error messages, ultimately contributing to better maintainability and ease of use for the Charms library.
The consistency in implementation across different functions and operation types is commendable, as it maintains code clarity and reduces the likelihood of inconsistencies in location tracking.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (5)
test/mod_merge_test.exs (3)
4-7: Improve test description for clarityWhile the test case correctly checks the behavior of
get_term/1for both submodules, the test description "attr" is not very informative. Consider renaming the test to better describe what it's actually testing.Here's a suggested improvement:
- test "attr" do + test "get_term/1 returns 1 for both SubMod0 and SubMod1" do assert 1 = SubMod0.get_term(1) assert 1 = SubMod1.get_term(1) end
9-13: Improve test description and consider splitting the testThe test case "func" checks multiple behaviors, but its description is not informative. Consider improving the test description and potentially splitting it into separate tests for clarity.
Here's a suggested improvement:
- test "func" do - assert SubMod0 = SubMod0.get_attr() - assert SubMod1 = SubMod1.get_attr() - assert SubMod0.get_attr_dup() == SubMod1.get_attr_dup() - end + describe "submodule attribute functions" do + test "get_attr/0 returns the module itself for both SubMod0 and SubMod1" do + assert SubMod0 = SubMod0.get_attr() + assert SubMod1 = SubMod1.get_attr() + end + + test "get_attr_dup/0 returns the same value for both SubMod0 and SubMod1" do + assert SubMod0.get_attr_dup() == SubMod1.get_attr_dup() + end + endThis change improves readability and makes the purpose of each test more explicit.
1-14: Overall feedback: Good start, but room for improvementThe test module provides a good starting point for testing the behavior of SubMod0 and SubMod1, likely after some kind of module merging operation. However, there are a few areas where it could be improved:
- Test descriptions could be more informative to clearly indicate what's being tested.
- Consider using ExUnit's
describeblocks to group related tests.- It might be beneficial to add more test cases to cover additional scenarios or edge cases.
To further improve test coverage and maintainability, consider:
- Adding tests for error cases or edge conditions.
- Using ExUnit's
setupblocks if there's any common setup needed for these tests.- If there are many more similar tests to add, consider using ExUnit's
doctestfunctionality for any documented examples in the main code.test/support/merge_mod.ex (1)
1-38: Well-structured and consistent module definitionsThe file defines two modules, SubMod0 and SubMod1, with consistent use of the Charms library and function signatures. Both modules implement get_term/2, get_attr/1, and get_attr_dup/1 functions with similar behavior. The slight difference in the get_term/2 implementation in SubMod1 (calling SubMod0.get_term/2) demonstrates a good use of module composition.
To further improve code quality:
- Consider the optimization suggested for SubMod1.get_term/2.
- Add documentation comments for each module and function to explain their purpose and usage.
- If these modules are part of a larger system, consider adding unit tests to ensure their behavior remains consistent as the codebase evolves.
Would you like assistance in generating documentation comments or unit tests for these modules?
lib/charms/jit.ex (1)
28-32: Approve renaming and scope expansion, suggest documentation update.The renaming of
clone_func_impltoclone_opsand the inclusion ofmemref.globalin the operation filtering criteria are good improvements. These changes better reflect the function's broader scope and enhance its functionality.Consider adding a brief function documentation to explain the purpose and scope of
clone_ops, especially highlighting its handling of bothfunc.funcandmemref.globaloperations. This would improve code maintainability and readability.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (9)
- bench/enif_merge_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/enif_tim_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/sort_benchmark.exs (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/defm/expander.ex (8 hunks)
- lib/charms/defm/pass/create_absent_func.ex (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/jit.ex (2 hunks)
- test/defm_test.exs (1 hunks)
- test/mod_merge_test.exs (1 hunks)
- test/support/merge_mod.ex (1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (3)
- lib/charms/defm/expander.ex
- lib/charms/defm/pass/create_absent_func.ex
- test/defm_test.exs
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (14)
test/mod_merge_test.exs (1)
1-2: LGTM: Proper module setup with ExUnitThe module is correctly set up using ExUnit.Case with
async: true, which is good for test performance. The module name follows Elixir naming conventions.bench/sort_benchmark.exs (2)
Line range hint
1-24: Summary: Improved consistency with minor update neededThe changes in this file have largely improved consistency by removing the
:arg_errargument from sorting function calls. This simplification aligns with the updated function signatures and addresses previous concerns about inconsistent argument usage.However, there's still a minor inconsistency in the benchmarking setup that needs to be addressed (as mentioned in the previous comment). Once this is resolved, the benchmarking code will be fully consistent and more accurately reflect the updated sorting function signatures.
Overall, these changes contribute to better code clarity and maintainability. Please make the suggested update to the benchmarking setup to complete the improvements.
2-4: Approve: Consistent removal of:arg_errargumentThe removal of the
:arg_errargument from all three sorting function calls (ENIFQuickSort.sort,ENIFMergeSort.sort, andENIFTimSort.sort) improves consistency and simplifies the function calls. This change addresses the inconsistency issue raised in previous reviews.To ensure that these changes align with the updated function signatures, please run the following script:
test/support/merge_mod.ex (2)
1-18: LGTM: SubMod0 module structure and implementationThe SubMod0 module is well-structured and implements the required functions correctly. The use of Charms and the alias for Charms.Term is appropriate. The functions get_term/2, get_attr/1, and get_attr_dup/1 are implemented as expected.
20-38: LGTM: SubMod1 module structureThe SubMod1 module is well-structured and implements the required functions. The use of Charms and the alias for Charms.Term is consistent with SubMod0. The functions get_attr/1 and get_attr_dup/1 are implemented correctly.
bench/enif_tim_sort.ex (4)
104-104: Good addition of the error constant.The introduction of the
@errmodule attribute is a positive change. It centralizes the error message definition, making it easier to maintain and update if needed in the future. This approach also ensures consistency in error reporting across the module.
105-108: Improved function signature and control flow.The changes to the
sortfunction are beneficial:
- Removing the
errparameter simplifies the function signature, making it cleaner and easier to use.- Replacing the
cond_brconstruct with anifstatement improves readability and makes the code more idiomatic.- The condition
enif_get_list_length(env, list, len_ptr) != 0correctly checks if the operation succeeded.These changes enhance the overall clarity and maintainability of the function.
115-119: Improved return logic and error handling.The changes to the return statements and error handling are well-implemented:
- Directly returning the result of
enif_make_list_from_arraysimplifies the code and removes unnecessary intermediate steps.- Raising an exception for an empty list using
enif_raise_exceptionis a more appropriate way to handle invalid input compared to returning an error value. This approach allows for better error propagation and handling in the calling code.- The use of the pipeline operator (
|>) withfunc.return()is an elegant and idiomatic way to return the result in Elixir.These changes improve the function's clarity, error handling, and adherence to Elixir conventions.
104-119: Overall improvements to thesortfunction.The changes made to the
ENIFTimSortmodule, particularly in thesortfunction, are well-implemented and bring several benefits:
- The introduction of the
@errmodule attribute centralizes error message definition.- Simplification of the function signature by removing the
errparameter.- Improved control flow with the use of an
ifstatement instead ofcond_br.- Better error handling by raising an exception for invalid input.
- More idiomatic Elixir code with the use of the pipeline operator for returning results.
These changes collectively enhance the readability, maintainability, and robustness of the code. Great job on these improvements!
lib/charms/jit.ex (3)
55-57: Approve simplification and consistency improvements.The changes in the
merge_modulesfunction are well-implemented:
- The simplified error handling for null modules improves code readability.
- Updating the function call from
clone_func_impltoclone_opsmaintains consistency with the earlier renaming.These modifications enhance the overall code quality without introducing any logical errors or performance issues.
Line range hint
62-89: Confirm unchangeddo_initfunction.The
do_initfunction remains unchanged in this update. It continues to serve its purpose of orchestrating the initialization of modules and the JIT compilation process. The lack of modifications here suggests that the changes made elsewhere in the file (such as renamingclone_func_impltoclone_ops) do not impact the overall initialization logic.
Line range hint
1-189: Summary of changes in Charms.JIT module.The modifications to the
Charms.JITmodule are well-implemented and improve the overall functionality and readability of the code:
- The renaming of
clone_func_impltoclone_opsand its expanded scope to includememref.globaloperations enhance the module's flexibility in handling different types of operations.- The simplification of error handling in the
merge_modulesfunction improves code readability.- Consistency is maintained throughout the module with appropriate updates to function calls.
These changes contribute to a more robust and maintainable JIT compilation process. The core functionality of the module, including the initialization process in
do_init, remains intact.bench/enif_merge_sort.ex (2)
107-119: Simplified control flow and improved error handling look goodThe replacement of
cond_brwith a standardifstatement enhances code readability. Usingenif_raise_exceptionto handle invalid input is appropriate and aligns with best practices for error handling in NIFs.
103-104: Ensure all calls toENIFMergeSort.sortuse the updated signatureThe
sortfunction signature has been changed by removing theerrparameter. Please verify that all calls toENIFMergeSort.sortin the codebase have been updated to use the new signature with onlyenvandlistas parameters.Run the following script to find any calls to
ENIFMergeSort.sortwith three or more arguments:
jackalcooper
force-pushed
the
simplify-examples
branch
from
f1609ca to
f3355f7
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (1)
bench/enif_merge_sort.ex (1)
107-118: LGTM: Improved control flow and error handling.The changes to the
sortfunction body are positive:
- The switch from
cond_brto anifstatement improves readability.- Directly returning the result of
enif_make_list_from_arraysimplifies the code structure.- Using
enif_raise_exceptionwith@errfor error handling is more idiomatic in Elixir.Consider adding more context to the error message, such as including the invalid input's length or type. This could help with debugging:
@err %ArgumentError{message: "list expected, got: #{inspect(invalid_input)}"}Then, update the error raising line:
enif_raise_exception(env, String.to_charlist(@err.message |> :erlang.iolist_to_binary |> String.replace("#{inspect(invalid_input)}", "#{inspect(list)}")))This change would provide more informative error messages without significantly increasing code complexity.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (16)
- bench/enif_merge_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/enif_quick_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/enif_tim_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/sort_benchmark.exs (1 hunks)
- bench/vec_add_int_list.ex (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/defm.ex (2 hunks)
- lib/charms/defm/expander.ex (10 hunks)
- lib/charms/defm/pass/create_absent_func.ex (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/intrinsic.ex (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/jit.ex (2 hunks)
- lib/charms/prelude.ex (1 hunks)
- test/defm_test.exs (1 hunks)
- test/mod_merge_test.exs (1 hunks)
- test/string_test.exs (1 hunks)
- test/support/merge_mod.ex (1 hunks)
- test/vec_add_test.exs (1 hunks)
✅ Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- bench/vec_add_int_list.ex
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (10)
- bench/sort_benchmark.exs
- lib/charms/defm/expander.ex
- lib/charms/defm/pass/create_absent_func.ex
- lib/charms/intrinsic.ex
- lib/charms/jit.ex
- lib/charms/prelude.ex
- test/defm_test.exs
- test/mod_merge_test.exs
- test/string_test.exs
- test/support/merge_mod.ex
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (9)
test/vec_add_test.exs (1)
17-17: Approved: Simplified SIMD function callThe removal of the unnecessary variable assignment
v1 =simplifies the code without changing its functionality. This change maintains the test's effectiveness in catching theArgumentErrorwhile making the code more concise.bench/enif_quick_sort.ex (3)
67-67: LGTM: Good addition of a reusable error message.The new module attribute
@errprovides a clear and consistent error message for invalid input. This is a good practice for maintaining code quality and improving error handling.
71-82: Excellent improvements to control flow and error handling.The changes to the
sortfunction body are well-done:
- Replacing
cond_brwith anifstatement improves readability.- Using
enif_raise_exceptionfor error handling is more explicit and consistent with Elixir practices.- Directly returning the result of
enif_make_list_from_arraysimplifies the code.These changes maintain the original logic while enhancing code quality and maintainability.
68-68: Approve signature change, but verify impact on calling code.The simplification of the
sortfunction signature by removing theerrparameter is a good improvement. It's consistent with the new@errmodule attribute for error handling.To ensure this change doesn't break existing code, please run the following script to check for any calls to the old function signature:
If the script returns any results, those calls will need to be updated to match the new signature.
✅ Verification successful
Verified: No calls to the old
sortfunction signature found.🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for calls to the old sort function signature # Test: Search for function calls with three arguments rg --type elixir 'ENIFQuickSort\.sort\([^,]+,[^,]+,[^,]+\)'Length of output: 61
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for calls to the old sort function signature # Test: Search for function calls with three arguments rg --type elixir 'ENIFQuickSort\.sort\([^,]+,[^,]+,[^,]+\)'Length of output: 61
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for calls to the old sort function signature # Test: Search for function calls with three arguments rg --type elixir 'ENIFQuickSort\.sort\([^,]+,[^,]+,[^,]+\)'Length of output: 61
bench/enif_tim_sort.ex (2)
98-98: LGTM: Good practice for error message centralization.The addition of the
@errmodule attribute is a positive change. It centralizes the error message, making it easier to maintain and update if needed. This practice enhances code readability and consistency in error handling.
99-112: LGTM: Improved readability and error handling, but verify impact on callers.The changes to the
sortfunction are generally positive:
- Simplified function signature by removing the
errparameter.- Improved readability by using an
ifstatement instead ofcond_br.- Streamlined return statements for more concise code.
- Consistent error handling using
enif_raise_exceptionwith the centralized error message.These changes enhance the overall code quality and maintainability. However, it's important to ensure that this new error handling approach doesn't break existing code that may have been expecting to handle errors differently.
To verify the impact of these changes, please run the following script:
✅ Verification successful
Verification Successful: No broken calls or error handling issues detected.
The changes to the
sortfunction have been thoroughly verified:
- No calls to
ENIFTimSort.sortwith three arguments were found outsidebench/enif_tim_sort.ex.- No error handling related to
ENIFTimSortthat requires updating was identified.These results confirm that the removal of the
errparameter and the streamlined error handling do not adversely affect the existing codebase.🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for potential breaking changes in error handling # Search for calls to ENIFTimSort.sort with 3 arguments (which would now be incorrect) echo "Searching for potentially broken calls to ENIFTimSort.sort:" rg --type elixir 'ENIFTimSort\.sort\(.+,.+,.+\)' --glob '!bench/enif_tim_sort.ex' # Search for any error handling related to ENIFTimSort that might need updating echo "Searching for potential error handling that might need updating:" rg --type elixir 'ENIFTimSort.*rescue|ENIFTimSort.*catch' --glob '!bench/enif_tim_sort.ex'Length of output: 444
bench/enif_merge_sort.ex (2)
103-103: LGTM: Good practice for error message centralization.The addition of the
@errmodule attribute is a positive change. It centralizes the error message definition, making it easier to maintain and ensure consistency in error reporting across the module.
104-104: LGTM: Function signature simplified.The removal of the
errparameter from thesortfunction signature is a good simplification. This change aligns well with the new error handling approach using the@errmodule attribute.To ensure this change doesn't break existing code, please verify all calls to this function have been updated. Run the following script to check for any remaining calls with three arguments:
✅ Verification successful
Verified: All calls to
ENIFMergeSort.sorthave been updated to use the two-argument signature.No further action required.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for any remaining calls to ENIFMergeSort.sort with three arguments # Test: Search for function calls to ENIFMergeSort.sort. Expect: Only two-argument calls. rg --type elixir 'ENIFMergeSort\.sort\s*\([^)]+,[^)]+,[^)]+\)'Length of output: 64
lib/charms/defm.ex (1)
188-191: Integration ofautocomplete_func_return/1into the compilation process is correctAdding the
autocomplete_func_return/1function to the pass composer ensures that functions without explicit return operations are properly handled during compilation.
jackalcooper
force-pushed
the
simplify-examples
branch
from
f3355f7 to
15c3069
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (1)
bench/enif_tim_sort.ex (1)
102-112: LGTM: Improved control flow and error handling.The changes to the
sortfunction body are good improvements:
- The
ifstatement is more readable than the previouscond_br.- Direct return and exception raising simplify the control flow.
- The use of
@errin the exception is consistent with the new module attribute.These changes maintain the original logic while improving code clarity and maintainability.
Consider adding a type spec for the
sortfunction to improve documentation and enable better static analysis:@spec sort(Env.t(), Term.t()) :: Term.t()
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (16)
- bench/enif_merge_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/enif_quick_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/enif_tim_sort.ex (1 hunks)
- bench/sort_benchmark.exs (1 hunks)
- bench/vec_add_int_list.ex (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/defm.ex (2 hunks)
- lib/charms/defm/expander.ex (10 hunks)
- lib/charms/defm/pass/create_absent_func.ex (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/intrinsic.ex (1 hunks)
- lib/charms/jit.ex (2 hunks)
- lib/charms/prelude.ex (1 hunks)
- test/defm_test.exs (1 hunks)
- test/mod_merge_test.exs (1 hunks)
- test/string_test.exs (1 hunks)
- test/support/merge_mod.ex (1 hunks)
- test/vec_add_test.exs (1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (15)
- bench/enif_merge_sort.ex
- bench/enif_quick_sort.ex
- bench/sort_benchmark.exs
- bench/vec_add_int_list.ex
- lib/charms/defm.ex
- lib/charms/defm/expander.ex
- lib/charms/defm/pass/create_absent_func.ex
- lib/charms/intrinsic.ex
- lib/charms/jit.ex
- lib/charms/prelude.ex
- test/defm_test.exs
- test/mod_merge_test.exs
- test/string_test.exs
- test/support/merge_mod.ex
- test/vec_add_test.exs
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (2)
bench/enif_tim_sort.ex (2)
98-98: LGTM: Good use of module attribute for error message.The addition of the
@errmodule attribute is a good practice. It centralizes the error message, making it easier to maintain and update if needed. The message is clear and descriptive.
99-99: LGTM: Function signature simplified.The removal of the
errparameter from thesortfunction signature is a good simplification, consistent with the new@errmodule attribute. This change improves the function's interface.To ensure this change doesn't break existing code, please verify all calls to this function:
Summary by CodeRabbit
Release Notes
New Features
ENIFQuickSort,ENIFMergeSort, andENIFTimSortmodules with streamlined error handling and improved return logic.ModMergeTest, to validate behaviors in submodules.Bug Fixes
ENIFQuickSortto raise exceptions for invalid arguments instead of returning error values.Documentation
ENIFQuickSort.Refactor
Charms.Defm.Expandermodule to maintain location context.handle_intrinsicfunction inCharms.Preludeto include location context in function calls.Charms.JITmodule for clarity and efficiency.Reference
Arwalk/zig-protobuf#34